Go Back   Clunk's Forums. > Product Reviews. > Reviews.

Reply
 
LinkBack (35) Thread Tools Display Modes

  2 links from elsewhere to this Post. Click to view. #11  
Old 10-10-2007, 21:21
Clunk's Avatar
Monkey Trousers.
Clunk's System Specs
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Manchester, UK
Posts: 11,789
Thanks: 809
Thanked 694 Times in 607 Posts
Default

4005Mhz
CPU-Z Validator Database


4141Mhz
CPU-Z Validator Database


And finally 4203Mhz - No screenie, it crashed
CPU-Z Validator Database

The highest I could go was 467x9, and I just managed to get a CPU-Z validation file from it...typically, the CPU-Z website has disappeared

Going for highest FSB possible, I tried 510x6 - this was doable on my P5K Deluxe...no go on the Maximus, in fact, I cant even post with 500xanything, and also, 490x7 wouldn't even boot - (Fixed with BIOS 0505, highest bootable FSB is now 480, but not stable, see further down the page.)

The problem here seems to be the flakey BIOS. With my previously stable settings, I restarted and the PC didn't post, this is also reminiscent of the Commando, with the error on the LCD Poster showing a random selection of errors from DET-DRAM (which often means dead RAM) to CPU-DET.

************************************************** ************************************************** *****

Continued...

I have been testing some more this afternoon, and I'm quite concerned about the Maximus now, or at least mine.

Aside from the flakey BIOS I mentioned earlier, I have been having RAM problems, in so much as, I have been unable to get stable with anything other than 5-5-5-15. Now the worrying thing is that the Maximus over volts the RAM by around 0.8v, and earlier this afternoon, the board wouldn't restart without physically unplugging the PSU. Again, these are exactly the same symptoms as on the Commando when it went on it's RAM killing spree, not once, but three times, and you can imagine that I wasn't too pleased when my first set of Ballistix suddenly died (** UPDATE 17-10-07:This also appears to be a weird BIOS problem with one particular set of Ballistix, as they work in the P5K Deluxe!, so they are not dead.).

I have replaced the ballistix with another set, and I am still having some strange issues.

One issue is that even with 11 hours stable settings, a restart to change some BIOS settings, results in no post, and the PSU has to be unplugged, or turned off and on for a few seconds before it will post.

I tried a different PSU - different brand, a Seasonic S12 and the same thing happens.

I am going to try a few other things and I'll report back with any findings....

Flashed back to the 04 BIOS, slightly better, but still cant restart without it hanging at any settings.

RAM clocking is a bit better with this BIOS as well.

CPU-Z Validator Database 3600/4-4-4-4

CPU-Z Validator Database 3600/3-3-3-3

CPU-Z Validator Database 3690/3-3-3-3


3780Mhz/3-3-3-3
CPU-Z Validator Database

3870Mhz/3-3-3-3
CPU-Z Validator Database


4005/3-3-3-3
CPU-Z Validator Database


4050Mhz/3-3-3-3 That's 900Mhz on the RAM at 3-3-3-3
CPU-Z Validator Database

4104/3-6-3-6
CPU-Z Validator Database


4113/3-6-3-6
CPU-Z Validator Database

Messing with the Dividers.

Previously, I wasnt able to even post when I used a divider, but after flashing back to BIOS 0401, they are working.

4104/5-5-5-12 1140Mhz 5:6
CPU-Z Validator Database

4104/4-4-4-4 1140Mhz 4:5
CPU-Z Validator Database

This is a request from Hornet.

3600Mhz CPU - 1200Mhz RAM 14Hrs Prime stable (I forgot the screenie, you'll just have to trust me )

CPU-Z Validator Database


One other interesting thing that I've noticed, is that, even through all the heaviest of testing, with quite high voltage (1.65v at times), the HR-09 heatsinks were cool to the touch, in fact, so much so, that I took them off to check they were making contact and they were. On my P5K, these got very hot, especially the one on the left of the CPU, that one got seriously hot, too hot to touch, so this is a great step forward as there will be less heat to get rid of in your case.

Testing 4x1GiB PC2-8500 Crucial Ballistix.

CPU-Z Validator Database


This is where I changed to BIOS 0505 and things started to get better. Vdroop is much less, and things overall seem to need less voltage, but for the following tests, I needed a lot of voltage to the Northbridge, as you can see from the pics. I did manage to reduce the NB voltage down quite a lot, but this depends highly on how many sticks of RAM you are running, how fast you are running them, and how tight the timings are. For most people, running 4x1GiB @ 800Mhz, or even 1066Mhz with reasonable timings, then a couple of extra notches of voltage to the NB should be sufficient.

3600Mhz CPU - 1066Mhz RAM 4-4-4-4
CPU-Z Validator Database


3600Mhz CPU - 800Mhz RAM 3-3-3-3

CPU-Z Validator Database

Highest FSB.

The Highest bootable (not stable) FSB I can hit with this board is 480, as opposed to 510FSB on the P5K Deluxe, hopefully this will change as the BIOS matures.
CPU-Z Validator Database

More later
Reply With Quote
Thanked By:
purecain (18-10-2007)

  #12  
Old 10-10-2007, 21:21
Clunk's Avatar
Monkey Trousers.
Clunk's System Specs
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Manchester, UK
Posts: 11,789
Thanks: 809
Thanked 694 Times in 607 Posts
Default

I've moved over to BIOS 0602 and now I can boot with 480x8

480x8

CPU-Z Validator Database

Absolutely no added benefits over 0505, apart from the use of the 8x multi, which isn't stable.

Futuremark - ORB - Project Comparison
15396

Futuremark - ORB - Project Comparison 15459


I have just beaten my previous highest overclocks on water.

4209Mhz on water
CPU-Z Validator Database

4382Mhz on hot water
CPU-Z Validator Database

The absolute maximum FSB I can hit on this board is 490, and that is with some serious tweaking and reduction of timings etc, so still not great.

CPU-Z Validator Database
Reply With Quote

  #13  
Old 10-10-2007, 21:21
Clunk's Avatar
Monkey Trousers.
Clunk's System Specs
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Manchester, UK
Posts: 11,789
Thanks: 809
Thanked 694 Times in 607 Posts
Default

reserved
Reply With Quote

  #14  
Old 10-10-2007, 21:21
Clunk's Avatar
Monkey Trousers.
Clunk's System Specs
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Manchester, UK
Posts: 11,789
Thanks: 809
Thanked 694 Times in 607 Posts
Default

Continued Testing with 4x1GiB Crucial Ballistix.
Same settings as above, 11 hours 59 mins prime stable.


4x1GiB 3600Mhz/800Mhz 4-4-4-4

CPU-Z Validator Database

4x1GiB 3600Mhz/1066Mhz 4-4-4-4
CPU-Z Validator Database


4x1GiB 3600Mhz/800Mhz 3-3-3-3
CPU-Z Validator Database

More later...
Reply With Quote

Conclusion
  #15  
Old 10-10-2007, 21:21
Clunk's Avatar
Monkey Trousers.
Clunk's System Specs
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Manchester, UK
Posts: 11,789
Thanks: 809
Thanked 694 Times in 607 Posts
Default Conclusion

Conclusion

Over the last few weeks, I have got to know the quirks of the Maximus, and in general, I have to say that most of the time, it wasn't a nice board to use, and here's why;

There was a warm restart problem, which meant that if you needed to restart the PC, be it by the reset button, or via restarting windows, the Maximus would fail to post every time. At first I suspected the PSU, as I had an identical problem with the Asus Commando and the Enermax Galaxy a few months ago, but even with a different brand of PSU (Seasonic), the problem was still there. Even a change of graphics card and several different sets of RAM didn't solve the problem. The only small speck of light at the end of the tunnel, was by raising the PCI-E frequency to 120, and this dramatically cut down the problem, but not completely - Enough is enough, it's a 180.00 motherboard, when all said and done, and this shouldn't be happening.

There was also the dubious issue of the RAM over volt, sometimes as much as 0.09v at idle, which I believe, could have contributed to killing a couple of sets of Ballistix (Killed one set, damaged another). One of the sets of RAM, flatly refused to work in the Maximus, until after BIOS 0505 was loaded, and later died completely - take from that what you will!

The layout on the Maximus was good at first glance, but later proved to be a bit of a pain, especially if you want to fit any larger PCI cards, as the bottom PCI slot would obscure some of the internal USB/Firewire headers, and the top PCI slot can be a real pig to get to, especially if you have a water cooler GPU and North Bridge, as I suspect that a lot of users of this board will have.

Overclocking wise, I reached my personal highest overclock on the Maximus and that was 4382Mhz, however, more down to earth overclocks for everyday use, required a significant amount more voltage than my P5K Deluxe did, and I suspect that this could have been fixed with some GTL REF tweaking and a more stable BIOS - that would have given the Maximus the edge it needs. Similarly, I was able to hit 510FSB with the same Q6600 on the P5K Deluxe, whereas the Maximus would only let me get to 490FSB.

The bundle of accessories was pretty good, and the inclusion of S.T.A.L.K.E.R. and 3dMark06 was nice, in fact, for a top end board, it is pretty much what you would expect. The only feature of note that was missing from the Maximus was E-SATA.

The BIOS - The shipping BIOS wasn't great, and the subsequent release wasn't much better. It wasn't until 0505 was released that things started to improve.

In the last year or so, I have used pretty much every Intel based Asus motherboard, and this is by no means the worst, but as far as buggy BIOSes go, this is right up there.

**UPDATE: 20-11-2007 - The latest BIOS release is 0901, and this appears to fix a lot of issues, which is excellent news.
Reply With Quote

  #16  
Old 10-10-2007, 22:35
Member
Grimpy's System Specs
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Posts: 49
Thanks: 0
Thanked 1 Time in 1 Post
Default

Nice review so far,mine is pencilled in for delivery on Friday.
Reply With Quote

  #17  
Old 11-10-2007, 00:03
supershanks's Avatar
Super Moderator
supershanks's System Specs
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Hamilton - Scotland
Posts: 4,530
Thanks: 4
Thanked 321 Times in 277 Posts
Default

Great review as ever Clunk, looks very tempting, in a warped kind of way I'm tempted I must admit , but I may opt for the Abit IX38 QuadGT. Look forward to seeing those benches
Reply With Quote

  #18  
Old 11-10-2007, 00:36
Clunk's Avatar
Monkey Trousers.
Clunk's System Specs
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Manchester, UK
Posts: 11,789
Thanks: 809
Thanked 694 Times in 607 Posts
Default

Benches on the way, but might be morning before I can post them..I've got eyestrain
Reply With Quote

  #19  
Old 11-10-2007, 01:02
supershanks's Avatar
Super Moderator
supershanks's System Specs
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Hamilton - Scotland
Posts: 4,530
Thanks: 4
Thanked 321 Times in 277 Posts
Default

Quote:
but might be morning before I can post them.
That's ok i can wait half an hour
Quote:
I've got eyestrain
would be worse::

Is there E-Sata ??

btw X38 compatable Memset may be handy.
Reply With Quote

  #20  
Old 11-10-2007, 01:21
Clunk's Avatar
Monkey Trousers.
Clunk's System Specs
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Manchester, UK
Posts: 11,789
Thanks: 809
Thanked 694 Times in 607 Posts
Default

yep, I suppose it would!

Nope, no E-SATA, which is a bit of an oversight in my view, especially considering the price.
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


LinkBacks (?)
LinkBack to this Thread: http://www.clunk.org.uk/forums/reviews/124-asus-maximus-formula-se-x38-living-review.html
Posted By For Type Date
ASUS Maximus Extreme / Formula SE *R.O.G.* || ***SAMMELTHREAD*** #2 - Seite 61 - Forum de Luxx This thread Refback 30-01-2010 19:10
Buena reviews de la maximus formula. This thread Refback 12-12-2009 17:14
Hardwareoverclock.com | Wasser und Zubehör | Asus Maximus Formula und WAKÜ ? This thread Refback 10-12-2009 19:10
Downgrade - e8400 - Asus Maximus Formula - Foro Lanparty Uruguay This thread Refback 08-11-2009 14:47
Entfernung der Heatpipe auf dem Asus Maximus - Wasserkühlung - Aqua Computer Forum This thread Refback 26-10-2009 23:30
Buena reviews de la maximus formula. This thread Refback 12-10-2009 12:47
Which will be better? ASUS MAXIMUS FORMULA or the Asus Striker Extreme 680i? - Page 2 - nV News Forums This thread Refback 09-10-2009 21:51
Buena reviews de la maximus formula. This thread Refback 07-10-2009 09:20
Buena reviews de la maximus formula. This thread Refback 05-10-2009 22:34
ASUSTeK Computer Inc.-Forum- my computer This thread Refback 31-08-2009 06:16
Good phenom 2 + mobo combo? This thread Refback 08-07-2009 16:10
LanParty • Ver Topic - Downgrade - e8400 - Asus Maximus Formula This thread Refback 08-06-2009 13:56
ASUSTeK Computer Inc.-Forum- my computer This thread Refback 19-04-2009 11:05
MaXiMuS ToPiC -=Formula I/II & Rampaged=- - Page 2 - Nokytech This thread Refback 12-04-2009 12:58
memorias ideales para asus formula special edition X38... - Comunidad N3D This thread Refback 10-04-2009 21:31
MaXiMuS ToPiC -=Formula I/II & Rampaged=- - Page 6 - Nokytech This thread Refback 09-03-2009 21:56
Infiniti M35 Extended Car Warranties, Infiniti Logo, Infiniti M45 Automatic Trunk Closer - Irishindependence This thread Refback 08-03-2009 10:03
My Antec 900 Water Cooled, finally... - Page 2 - Overclock.net - Overclocking.net This thread Refback 27-02-2009 19:16
ASUSTeK Computer Inc.-Forum- Best Bios Setting for Maximus Formula This thread Refback 22-02-2009 07:33
3Dhue - 3D, VFX, ANIMASJON, GRAFISK DESIGN :: Vis emnet - Et lite overklokkingsprosjekt This thread Refback 04-02-2009 12:12
CPU/NB/Motherboard cooling recomdations and Ideas... - Novatech Community Forums This thread Refback 01-02-2009 09:36
new build maximus formula wont post---helpplease :) This thread Refback 28-01-2009 07:59
Official ASUS X38 Boards: P5E, P5E3 - Info/BIOS Thread - Page 15 - XtremeSystems Forums This thread Refback 20-01-2009 15:45
Best Motherboard for a Q6600 This thread Refback 20-01-2009 12:39
Hardwareoverclock.com | Wasser und Zubehör | Asus Maximus Formula und WAKÜ ? This thread Refback 12-01-2009 01:12
Good phenom 2 + mobo combo? This thread Refback 09-01-2009 01:55
ASUSTeK Computer Inc.-Forum- My new pc is crashing, MACHINE_CHECK_EXCEPTION This thread Refback 01-01-2009 22:21
MaXiMuS ToPiC -=Formula I/II & Rampaged=- - Page 6 - Nokytech This thread Refback 14-12-2008 20:34
MaXiMuS ToPiC -=Formula I/II & Rampaged=- - Page 2 - Nokytech This thread Refback 10-12-2008 13:17
OC maximus formula et P5E [BDD] - CPU - Overclocking, Cooling & Tuning - FORUM HardWare.fr This thread Refback 05-11-2008 09:13
Ava Direct or Maingear? - Page 7 - [H]ard|Forum This thread Refback 11-10-2008 14:21
- Post 273164 - Forums by Vmodtech.com - Increase your Force This thread Refback 27-09-2008 10:39
bios booting questions - Overclock.net - Overclocking.net This thread Refback 22-09-2008 15:35
[Sammelthread] Asus Maximus Extreme / Formula SE R.O.G. (Intel X38) [5] - Seite 75 - Forum de Luxx This thread Refback 17-09-2008 19:03
OC Q6xx0~e6x50/Asus Maximus Formula SE - Page 6 - Nokytech This thread Refback 31-01-2008 14:51



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 18:04.


vBulletin skins developed by: eXtremepixels
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SEO by vBSEO 3.3.2
Copyright© Clunk.org.uk 2010
| Home | Register | FAQ | Calendar | Today's Posts | Search | New Posts |